Doctor Who has survived an awful lot.
We’ve seen the Doctor fall off a giant telescope, absorb a lethal amount of radiation (twice), and even bump their head on the Tardis console, yet they still walked away to tell the tale.
True, they might not have had the same face after these incidents, but that’s pretty run of the mill for Time Lords.
It’s strange, then, that for the first time since 2005 and Doctor Who’s triumphant return that it feels like the beloved sci-fi series is in peril.
Low viewing figures, mixed critical reception, and growing fan antipathy have dogged the show over the last few series, and there’s a fear amongst fans that the Doctor might be done for.
Get personalised updates on Doctor Who
Wake up to find news on your TV shows in your inbox every morning with Metro’s TV Newsletter.
Sign up to our newsletter and then select your show in the link we’ll send you so we can get TV news tailored to you.
Yet, do you know who else has believed the Doctor was defeated over the years? The Daleks… and the Cybermen… and The Master.
In fact, countless villains over the years have considered the Doctor to be beaten, only to be proven wrong, and new rumours have me optimistic that the Last of the Time Lords can do the impossible once again.
We’ll start with the bad news. There are unverified reports online that Disney is done with Doctor Who and that they won’t be helping produce another season.
On paper, that sounds like a massive blow, but before you start wailing into your Tom Baker scarf, there is some good news.
To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web
browser that
supports HTML5
video
Supposedly, the BBC is close to finding a new partner for the beleaguered series, which will allow them to continue Doctor Who in some form or another.
What form will the show take next? Who knows?
To paraphrase the Doctor, regeneration is a lottery; you never know what you’re going to get, and so is renewal in the TV world.
What I do know is that whoever takes it over is unlikely to have pockets as deep as Disney – unless it’s Apple TV Plus, they’re Scrooge McDuck rich – which means Who’s going to have to make some adjustments.
And you know what? I think that’s great.
The BBC may have grand ambitions for Doctor Who to be a big-budget affair like the MCU or other modern sci-fi series, but that’s not what audiences watch the show for.
They watch it because they love the characters, the stories, and the incredible creativity of the writers.
The House of Mouse’s cash might have allowed the Doctor to go on bigger adventures than ever before through impressive special effects, incredible sets, and stunning CGI, but it also robbed the show of some of its underdog spirit.
Now, the stereotype of every Doctor Who monster being made of a pedal bin with bubble wrap glued to it is a bit outdated, as is the belief that it’s filmed exclusively in Welsh quarries.
Yet it is true that the series’ limited budget forced the show’s writers and producers to get creative, which gave Doctor Who a certain charm all of its own.
Monsters felt more real because they were just people in goofy costumes, not CGI behemoths.
Alien worlds felt tangible because they weren’t green screens, they were… well, to be honest, they were Welsh quarries, but they used other places in Wales too!
More than that, I think the limited budgets pushed writers and producers to think their way out of problems, rather than throwing cash at them.
There are plenty of examples from across the show’s history but the best example I can think of involves the iconic Tardis.
Have you ever wondered why the Tardis is a blue police phone box? No, it’s not because the chameleon circuit is broken. It’s because the BBC didn’t want to pay for a new prop every week.
That’s right, one of the most important pieces of iconography in British pop culture was born because some backroom accountant wanted to save a couple of quid.
Glibness aside, I do think a big problem in recent years has been an overreliance on spectacle over character and plot (most notably in the last two season finales).
With that in mind then I’m hopeful that whoever takes on Who will make Russell T Davies and his writers realise expensive CGI isn’t a substitute for a coherent story.
So, what I’m saying is that Disney dropping Doctor Who may wound the show. It may even force Doctor Who to change its face once again, but change can be for the better.
Do you have a story you’d like to share? Get in touch by emailing jess.austin@metro.co.uk.
Share your views in the comments below.
